Aspect and State
Aspect and State:
~ている vs. ~てある
Learn how Japanese describes an action happening now, a condition that remains, and a condition someone deliberately prepared.
नेपालीमा सजिलो व्याख्या • Japanese examples • Romaji • English meanings • Quick practice
1. The core difference / मुख्य फरक
Both forms describe a situation connected to an action, but they focus on different things.
What is happening, or what state exists?
Simple English: An action is in progress, or something is in a state resulting from a change.
नेपाली: कुनै काम अहिले भइरहेको छ, वा कुनै परिवर्तन भएपछि बनेको अवस्था अहिले पनि कायम छ भन्ने जनाउँछ। काम कसले गर्यो भन्ने कुरा मुख्य हुँदैन।
What has someone deliberately done?
Simple English: Someone did something intentionally, and the result is still there.
नेपाली: कसैले कुनै उद्देश्यले जानाजानी काम गरेको छ र त्यस कामको परिणामस्वरूप बनेको अवस्था अझै कायम छ भन्ने अर्थ दिन्छ। काम गर्ने व्यक्ति प्रायः उल्लेख गरिँदैन।
2. ~ている: ongoing action and resulting state
~ている is made by attaching いる to the て-form of a verb. Its meaning depends on the verb and the situation.
क्रियाको て-form पछि いる जोडेर ~ている बनाइन्छ। यसको अर्थ क्रियाको प्रकार र प्रसङ्गअनुसार बुझ्नुपर्छ। यसको दुई मुख्य प्रयोग छन्।
A. Action in progress / भइरहेको काम (Continuous)
English: The action is happening now or around the present time.
नेपाली: काम सुरु भइसकेको छ र अहिले पनि चलिरहेको छ। नेपालीमा प्रायः “गरिरहेको छ/छु/छन्” भनेर बुझ्न सकिन्छ।
| Japanese | Romaji | नेपाली | English |
|---|---|---|---|
| 母は料理をしている。 | Haha wa ryōri o shite iru. | आमा खाना पकाइरहनुभएको छ। | Mother is cooking. |
| 私は日本語を勉強している。 | Watashi wa nihongo o benkyō shite iru. | म जापानी भाषा पढिरहेको छु। | I am studying Japanese. |
B. Resulting state / कामपछि बनेको अवस्था
English: A change happened, and the resulting condition continues.
नेपाली: कुनै घटना वा परिवर्तन भइसकेको छ र त्यसको परिणामस्वरूप बनेको अवस्था अहिले पनि छ। यहाँ काम भइरहेको होइन; त्यसको नतिजा देखाइएको हो।
| Japanese | Romaji | नेपाली | English |
|---|---|---|---|
| 田中さんは結婚している。 | Tanaka-san wa kekkon shite iru. | तानाका-सान विवाहित हुनुहुन्छ। | Mr./Ms. Tanaka is married. |
| 電気が消えている。 | Denki ga kiete iru. | बत्ती निभेको छ। | The light is off. |
~ている with intransitive verbs / 自動詞 (अकर्मक क्रिया)
An intransitive verb (自動詞・じどうし) describes something that happens or changes without a direct object. The subject itself changes state. With many change-of-state intransitive verbs, ~ている describes the state after the change.
अकर्मक क्रिया ले सीधा कर्म नलिई आफैँ हुने वा परिवर्तन हुने घटना जनाउँछ। यस्ता धेरै परिवर्तन जनाउने क्रियासँग ~ている जोडिँदा परिवर्तन भइसकेपछिको अवस्था देखाउँछ।
| Dictionary form | Meaning | ~ている form | State meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| 開く(あく) | to open (by itself / become open) | 開いている | is open |
| 閉まる(しまる) | to close / become closed | 閉まっている | is closed |
| 壊れる(こわれる) | to break | 壊れている | is broken |
| 落ちる(おちる) | to fall | 落ちている | has fallen / is lying fallen |
Three clear examples of ~ている
बच्चा पार्कमा खेलिरहेको छ।
The child is playing in the park.
झ्याल खुला छ।
The window is open.
उनी टोकियोमा बस्छन्।
He lives in Tokyo.
3. ~てある: a deliberately created state
~てある describes a condition that remains because someone intentionally performed an action for a reason. The person who did it is often not mentioned; the sentence focuses on the prepared result.
~てある ले कसैले कुनै उद्देश्य वा तयारीका लागि जानाजानी काम गरेको र त्यसको परिणाम अहिले पनि कायम रहेको अवस्था जनाउँछ। काम गर्ने व्यक्ति महत्त्वपूर्ण नभएर तयार पारिएको अवस्था महत्त्वपूर्ण हुन्छ।
~てある with transitive verbs / 他動詞 (सकर्मक क्रिया)
A transitive verb (他動詞・たどうし) acts on a direct object: someone opens a window, writes a name, or places a book. In ~てある sentences, the affected thing is commonly marked with が (or sometimes は), while the verb appears in its て-form + ある.
सकर्मक क्रिया ले कुनै वस्तु वा व्यक्तिमाथि गरिने काम जनाउँछ। ~てある मा कामको असर परेको वस्तुलाई प्रायः が (वा प्रसङ्गअनुसार は) ले चिनाइन्छ। क्रिया चाहिँ て-form + ある हुन्छ।
| Transitive verb | Meaning | ~てある form | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| 開ける(あける) | to open something | 開けてある | has been opened and left open intentionally |
| 書く(かく) | to write something | 書いてある | has been written (and is there) |
| 並べる(ならべる) | to arrange / line up | 並べてある | has been arranged (ready / on purpose) |
| 置く(おく) | to put / place something | 置いてある | has been placed there |
Three clear examples of ~てある
बैठक कोठाको ढोका (कसैले) खोलेर राखेको छ।
The meeting room door has been opened and left open (ready).
डेस्कमाथि नाम लेखिएको छ।
A name has been written on the desk.
पाहुनाहरूका लागि कुर्सीहरू मिलाएर राखिएका छन्।
The chairs have been arranged for the guests.
उदाहरण: 資料が準備してある。 (Shiryō ga junbi shite aru.) — कागजातहरू तयार पारेर राखिएका छन्।
In everyday Japanese, ~てある often suggests preparation or a purposeful arrangement, but the exact nuance comes from context.
4. Direct contrast: ~ている vs. ~てある
Look at the same window. The visible condition may be similar—open—but the speaker’s focus is different.
एउटै झ्याल खुला छ। तर वाक्यअनुसार वक्ताले त्यसको अवस्था मात्र बताइरहेको हुन सक्छ, वा कसैले उद्देश्यपूर्वक खोलेर राखेको कुरा जनाइरहेको हुन सक्छ।
झ्याल खुला छ।
The window is open.
Focus: the current state. The window became open; how or why it opened is not the point. It may have opened naturally, accidentally, or because someone opened it.
झ्याल कसैले खोलेर राखेको छ।
The window has been opened and left open (intentionally).
Focus: the purposeful action and its result. Someone opened it—perhaps to let fresh air in—and it remains open.
| Point | ~ている | ~てある |
|---|---|---|
| Main focus | Ongoing action or current resulting state | Result of an intentional action |
| Typical verb type in this contrast | Intransitive (自動詞) | Transitive (他動詞) |
| Question it answers | What state is it in? / What is happening? | What has someone done and left ready? |
| Example | 窓が開いている。 Mado ga aite iru. | 窓が開けてある。 Mado ga akete aru. |
| Natural Nepali sense | झ्याल खुला छ। | झ्याल खोलेर राखिएको छ। |
5. Quick summary / झट्ट सम्झनुहोस्
~ている
Action is happening / state exists
काम भइरहेको छ वा परिवर्तनपछि बनेको अवस्था छ।
Ask: “What is happening? What state is it in?”
~てある
Someone did it on purpose; result remains
कसैले उद्देश्यपूर्वक गरेर राखेको छ; परिणाम अझै छ।
Ask: “What has someone prepared or done?”
~てある = “कसैले गरेर राखेको छ।”
यो सम्झने सजिलो तरिका हो; वास्तविक अर्थ बुझ्न सधैँ क्रिया र प्रसङ्ग पनि हेर्नुहोस्।
6. Quick practice quiz / अभ्यास
Choose the best form for each situation. Submit to see your score and explanations.
